In today’s tightening insurance market, condominium associations are finding themselves under the microscope, not just for their structural integrity, but for their financial planning as well. One increasingly critical factor is the presence and quality of a reserve study. Once considered just a budgeting tool, reserve studies are now a key metric insurers and actuaries use to assess a condo’s long-term risk and determine coverage terms. With premiums on the rise and underwriters becoming more selective, having a current, professionally conducted reserve study could mean the difference between affordable insurance, or none at all. As more states push for legislation mandating reserve funding, condo boards must be prepared to show that they’re planning for the future.
The financial scrutiny on HOAs is increasing, as a result of rising concerns over aging buildings and deferred maintenance. These concerns were brought to light after the tragic Surfside condominium collapse in 2021. In response, lenders and insurers have become more cautious, imposing stricter requirements before financing or underwriting properties. Underfunded reserves and unresolved maintenance issues can now jeopardize a community’s access to loans or insurance. In this rapidly evolving environment, reserve studies have taken on new significance and are now critical for both financial planning and risk management. A professional reserve study not only guides responsible budgeting but also signals the community is proactive and financially sound. As expectations continue to rise, HOAs must adapt by embracing transparency, long-term planning, and a more strategic approach to maintaining their assets.
A reserve study is an essential planning document used by HOAs to anticipate future repair and replacement costs for shared components such as roofs, elevators, and pavement. It consists of two key aspects: a physical inspection of the property’s major elements and a financial analysis that projects long-term funding needs. Together, these components help associations plan for inevitable capital expenses and set appropriate reserve contributions. Reserve studies are more than just a budgeting tool, they now play a critical role in how lenders and insurers evaluate risk. Lenders use them to gauge an association’s fiscal responsibility, looking for signs that the community is financially prepared to maintain the property over time. Meanwhile, insurers rely on them during underwriting to assess the likelihood of future claims tied to deferred maintenance or component failure. In this time of heightened scrutiny, a current and accurate reserve study sends a clear message that the community is proactive, financially stable, and committed to long-term sustainability.
Inadequate reserves pose a significant financial risk for homeowner associations (HOAs) and condominium boards, especially when it leads to deferred maintenance and asset deterioration. Without sufficient funds set aside for future repairs or replacements, minor issues can escalate into costly emergencies. Deferred maintenance not only affects a property’s safety and functionality but also its long-term value. As essential systems like roofs, plumbing, and elevators age without proper care, emergency repairs become both inevitable and more expensive than proactive maintenance. One of the most immediate consequences of underfunded reserves is the increased likelihood of special assessments—unexpected financial demands on homeowners that can deter buyers and raise concerns for mortgage lenders. Low reserve funds are often seen as a red flag, signaling financial instability. Insurance carriers are also taking note, with inadequate or undocumented reserves potentially leading to higher premiums or even denial of coverage. Recent data from the Foundation for Community Association Research highlights growing financial pressure across communities, with 91% of association professionals citing unexpected cost increases due to inflation. In response, many plan to raise assessments or cut expenses, including reserve contributions and maintenance projects. These trends underscore the urgent need for proactive, realistic financial planning to protect both property and homeowner interests.
In today’s real estate landscape, reserve funding has become a key factor in mortgage lending decisions. Institutions like Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) have increasingly integrated reserve data into their underwriting guidelines to assess the financial strength of a community. These agencies now require evidence of adequate reserve contributions for mortgage approval in many condominium and HOA projects. Inadequate reserves or outdated financial documentation can disqualify a community from eligibility, directly impacting home values and marketability. Lenders view reserve data through the lens of risk modeling, considering not only the level of contributions but also the percentage of funded reserves and the recency of reserve studies. These elements help determine whether a community can meet future repair obligations without resorting to special assessments, which could destabilize homeowner finances and impact loan repayment. A current and well-supported reserve study reassures lenders that the property is being responsibly maintained and is less likely to experience sudden financial or structural distress. Ultimately, reserve studies have become essential tools for protecting long-term loan collateral; helping lenders mitigate risk while ensuring sustainable communities for homeowners.
Proactive reserve planning is one of the most effective ways for community associations to mitigate financial risk and ensure lasting stability. Boards should prioritize updating their reserve studies every 3 years, or more frequently if significant changes occur within the property. These studies serve as the foundation for understanding a community’s long-term capital needs and should be conducted by professionals with expertise in engineering, architecture, or finance. Working with qualified experts ensures projections are accurate, comprehensive, and based on the physical needs of the property, not only financial assumptions. Once a study is completed, its findings should directly inform annual budgets and capital improvement plans. Rather than treating reserves as an afterthought, boards should use the data to align current contributions with forecasted future expenses, helping avoid costly special assessments or emergency repairs. Sharing reserve plans and funding levels with potential buyers, lenders, and insurance providers builds trust and confidence. When communities demonstrate that they’re financially prepared for the future, they become more appealing to all stakeholders and better positioned to be ready for any unexpected challenges. Proactive planning isn’t just good practice, it’s a strategic safeguard for the entire community.
In the aftermath of the 2021 Surfside condominium collapse, Miami-Dade County has become a leading example of how reserve studies can be used to mitigate financial risk in condo communities. In response to new state laws, associations are now required to conduct structural inspections and comprehensive reserve studies for aging buildings to ensure funding is present for critical repairs. These studies have become necessary for securing insurance coverage and loan approvals, as many insurers and lenders will not work with associations that lack adequately funded reserves. As a result, many communities have adopted more proactive financial planning strategies, such as increasing reserve contributions to avoid special assessments and maintain property values. This communal shift has improved financial stability and reduced the risk for both residents and stakeholders alike.
With growing concerns about building safety and financial stability, states like Florida, California, and Illinois are leading the way with new legislation aimed at strengthening reserve practices. For example, Florida has enacted sweeping laws requiring structural inspections and fully funded reserves for certain buildings near coastal or high-risk areas. California and Illinois are exploring similar reforms, pushing for more vigilant oversight of reserve studies, transparency, and long-term financial planning. These changes reflect a broader trend: state regulators are recognizing that inadequate reserves pose not just a financial threat, but a public safety issue. Alongside legislative action, there is increasing momentum within the industry for standardized best practices. Professionals across the community association, insurance, and lending sectors are calling for clearer disclosure requirements, minimum funding thresholds, and regular structural assessments to become the standard nationwide. There is also a growing call for tighter collaboration between reserve study providers, insurers, and mortgage underwriters to create more accurate risk profiles and sustainable financial plans for communities. As these regulations and standards evolve, board members and property managers will need to stay informed and embrace proactive planning as a critical component of responsible community stewardship.
In today’s rapidly shifting financial and regulatory landscape, outdated reserve planning can leave your community vulnerable to unexpected expenses, lender rejections, and insurance complications. A current reserve study is more than just a planning tool; it’s your first line of defense against financial risk. By maintaining an up-to-date reserve analysis, associations can align annual budgets with long-term needs, communicate with transparency, and present an enhanced risk profile to buyers, lenders, and insurers alike. In other words, staying ahead on reserve planning means staying ahead of potential hurdles.
Whether you’re an insurer, lender, property manager, or reserve specialist, understanding the financial health of a homeowners association is essential. Reserve studies now play a central role in risk mitigation, influencing everything from mortgage approvals to insurance underwriting. They reveal whether a community is prepared for the future or sitting on the edge of financial instability. For professionals across the industry, engaging with accurate, well-executed reserve data ensures better decision-making, reduces exposure to risk, and supports long-term sustainability for the communities you serve.
To request a proposal, please visit us here.
Written by James Newby, Architectural Engineer
